I really like the new metro / modern / Microsoft Design... there is a specific theme for Orchard already out there (linked below) that is along the lines of what I'm looking for, but I definitely want it to look unique (but not crazy):
The AC script-style logo on my existing site will remain... I have an EPS that I've attached. I also want to include the MVP logo on the left side of my site (there's a vertical & horizontal version I have copies of). These two logos would be on all pages along with the typical social icons.
I also want to leverage the same color scheme of my current site, primarily the dark blue with orange accents, but mostly a white background vs. what I currently have. Also, I need styles for H1-H4 and hyperlinks as well as callouts (blockquotes).
Note the metro design linked above has the three columns in the footer... I'd like that included as well.
Finally, I want to retain the "Translate this page" control that's in the top-right of my site in the sidebar of the design along with a search control, and tag cloud.